Cash Gift versus Stock Gift
When you make a charitable gift of cash, you get a charitable income tax deduction only. When you make a charitable gift of the same value with appreciated stock, you get the same charitable income tax deduction and you avoid capital gains tax on all of your capital gain. The more highly appreciated the security, the more capital gains tax you will avoid.
The chart below shows how making a gift with appreciated stock can save substantially more taxes than making the same size gift with cash.
What is the advantage of giving appreciated stock instead of cash?
|
|
Cash Gift
|
Stock Gift
|
|
a. Gift Value
|
$10,000
|
$10,000
|
|
b. Income tax deduction
|
$10,000
|
$10,000
|
|
c. Income tax saved (at 37% rate)*
|
$3,700
|
$3,700
|
|
|
|
d. Purchase price
|
-
|
$1,000
|
|
e. Increase in value (a - d)
|
-
|
$9,000
|
|
f. Tax avoided on gain (at 20% rate)*
|
-
|
$1,800
|
|
|
|
g. Total tax savings (c + f)
|
$3,700
|
$5,500
|
*assumes donor itemized deductions
Should I make a gift of securities that have lost value?
No! If you sell securities that have lost value, you can net that capital loss against capital gains. Even if you cannot take a deduction for loss securities this year, there is a five-year carry forward. If you want to make a gift of loss securities, sell the securities and take the capital loss. You can then donate the proceeds of your sale to Pine Street Inn and use the capital loss to offset future capital gain.
What happens if I give securities that I bought less than one year ago?
The charitable deduction available for property you have owned for 12 months or less, so-called "short term capital gain" property, is limited to either its current full value or what you paid for it, whichever is less. In this case, your deduction is limited to 60% of your adjusted gross income rather than the usual 30%. For example, if you give stock worth $10,000 that you purchased nine months ago for $1,000, your charitable deduction will be $1,000, not $10,000.
Is it easy to make a gift of publicly-traded securities?
Yes. Whether you plan to give one share or one thousand shares, it is easy to give your publicly-traded securities to us.
Give securities and receive payments for life
Another option for giving securities is through a life income plan. Giving securities through a life income plan allows you to provide income for yourself or others you care about and then provide support to Pine Street. Here is how it works:
- You transfer securities to the life income plan.
- During the term of the life income plan, you receive payments from the plan each year, typically for life.
- When the life income plan ends, its remaining principal goes to support Pine Street.
Using securities to fund a life income plan typically will reduce your income taxes, providing tax savings if you itemize, and reduce or eliminate your capital gains taxes.
There are several life income plan options to choose from. The one that is right for you will depend on a variety of factors. Please let us know if you would like to learn more.
Dan Yoder would like to make a $10,000 gift to Pine Street Inn. While he could write a check for this amount, he will be able to save even more in taxes by giving stock worth $10,000 instead. After reviewing his plans with his investment advisor, he decides to give shares of Poptropica Corporation worth $10,000. He paid just $1,000 for these shares when he bought them 20 years ago.
Benefits
- Dan will earn an immediate income tax charitable deduction of $10,000, which will save him $3,700 (37% tax), provided he itemizes.
- Dan may deduct up to 30% of his adjusted gross income in the year of the gift, with a five year carry-forward period.
- He will avoid tax on $9,000 of capital gain, which will save him an additional $1,800 (20% tax).
- He will gain the satisfaction of making a $10,000 gift to Pine Street Inn.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are publicly-traded securities?
Publicly-traded securities are stocks, bonds, and other investment vehicles whose values are readily available from an established securities market. For example, stocks listed on the New York or NASDAQ stock exchanges are publicly-traded securities.
Are mutual fund shares publicly-traded securities?
Although mutual funds are sold by individual mutual fund companies rather than on an exchange, the same charitable contribution rules apply to mutual fund shares as to shares of publicly-traded securities.
What are the tax benefits of contributing publicly-traded securities?
You can save income tax and capital gains tax when you give shares of a publicly-traded security that you have owned for a year or more.
What is the income tax benefit?
If you have held your securities for more than one year, you may deduct from your taxable income the full fair market value of your shares as of the date of your donation, regardless of what you paid for them. Your deduction is limited to 30% of your adjusted gross income. You may, however, carry forward any unused portion of your deduction for up to five additional years.
What is the capital gains tax benefit?
When you donate publicly-traded securities that have increased in value, and you have owned the securities for more than one year, you do not have to report any of your capital gain in the securities. If you were to sell these securities yourself, you would owe capital gains tax on the difference between the sale price and the amount you paid for them.
Should I give my securities or sell them and give the proceeds?
You should give your securities directly to Pine Street Inn. This way, you will avoid paying tax on any capital gain you have in your securities. If you sell your securities first and then give us the proceeds, you will have to pay capital gains tax on all of your capital gain, an unnecessary and potentially substantial cost to you.
Make a gift of publicly-traded securities to Pine Street Inn and potentially save income tax and capital gains tax, too.